Adam Smith
The Scottish philosopher of The Wealth of Nations and The Theory of Moral Sentiments. The pin factory, the butcher's self-interest, the village that paid in nails, the clipped coin, the wings of paper money, and the invisible hand that appears only once, read from the original texts.
An Invisible Hand That Appears Once
Adam Smith (1723-1790) was a Scottish moral philosopher, commonly called the father of economics. His name usually arrives together with the phrase "invisible hand." Yet the phrase appears exactly once in the whole of The Wealth of Nations (1776), and exactly once in his earlier book, The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759).
Neither time is it the grand conclusion of a theory of the market. In The Wealth of Nations it turns up in a passage on why a merchant prefers to put his capital into domestic rather than foreign industry; in The Theory of Moral Sentiments, in a passage on how a rich man's harvest ends up shared among the poor. The questions Smith actually spent his life on were different ones. How do strangers come to cooperate? And how does a person learn to see himself through the eyes of others?
Life
The Son of a Customs Officer in Kirkcaldy
Smith was baptised on 5 June 1723 in Kirkcaldy, a small port on the east coast of Scotland. His exact date of birth is not recorded. His father, comptroller of customs at Kirkcaldy, had died a few months before he was born, and Smith grew up as his mother's only child. He never married and stayed with his mother until her death.
Dugald Stewart, who wrote his biography in 1793, preserved one episode from his childhood. At about three, while visiting his uncle, Smith was playing alone at the door when a band of vagrants carried him off; his uncle pursued them and recovered the boy in a nearby wood.
Glasgow and Oxford
In 1737, at fourteen, Smith entered the University of Glasgow and heard the lectures of the moral philosopher Francis Hutcheson, whom Stewart says his students remembered as eloquent. In 1740 he went to Balliol College, Oxford, on a scholarship, and was deeply disappointed by the teaching there. In Book V of The Wealth of Nations he would write that at Oxford "the greater part of the public professors have, for these many years, given up altogether even the pretence of teaching."
The Lectern and The Theory of Moral Sentiments
Back in Scotland, Smith made his name from 1748 with public lectures on rhetoric and literature in Edinburgh. In 1751 he became professor of logic at Glasgow, and the following year moved to the chair of moral philosophy. His course had four parts: natural theology, ethics, justice, and the regulations founded not on justice but on expediency, which is to say economic policy. The ethics part became The Theory of Moral Sentiments in 1759. Around this time he formed a lifelong friendship with the philosopher David Hume.
Tutor to a Duke
The book brought him an unexpected post. The politician Charles Townshend, impressed by it, wanted Smith as tutor to his stepson, the young Duke of Buccleuch. In 1764 Smith resigned his chair and left for the Continent with the Duke.
They spent eighteen months in Toulouse, travelled through Geneva, and reached Paris around the end of 1765, staying until the following October. In Paris Smith mixed with the physiocrats, among them François Quesnay and Anne Robert Jacques Turgot. The book he had begun in Toulouse to pass the time would become The Wealth of Nations.
The Wealth of Nations and the Customs House
Home again in 1766, Smith worked for nearly ten years at his mother's house in Kirkcaldy on An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, which appeared in March 1776. Hume died that August.
In 1778 Smith was appointed a commissioner of customs for Scotland and moved to Edinburgh, where he spent his last twelve years. The great critic of trade restrictions now sat on the board that collected duties; according to Stewart, much of his increased income went to charity given in secret.
In July 1790, sensing the end, Smith asked his friends again and again to burn his manuscripts. When they did so on the spot, he was visibly relieved and received his guests that evening in his usual manner. Leaving the Sunday supper early, he took his leave with "I believe we must adjourn this meeting to some other place," and died a few days later. The few essays spared from the fire were published in 1795 as Essays on Philosophical Subjects.
Core Ideas
The Pin Factory
The Wealth of Nations opens with a small workshop: the pin factory of Book I, chapter 1. A man unused to the work, making pins alone, could scarcely make one in a day and certainly not twenty. But in a small factory Smith had seen, the work was split into about eighteen operations. One man draws out the wire, another straightens it, a third cuts it, a fourth points it, and so on to the head.
Those ten persons, therefore, could make among them upwards of forty-eight thousand pins in a day.
That is 4,800 per person. Men who alone could not make twenty pins produced, by dividing the work, 240 times as much and perhaps 4,800 times as much. What makes a nation rich is not a pile of gold and silver but the productive power of labour, and the greatest force raising that power is the division of labour. This is what the first sentence of the book says.
The Butcher's Self-Interest
Who designed the division of labour, then? No one's wisdom, Smith answers. It is the slow consequence of "the propensity to truck, barter, and exchange one thing for another" (Book I, chapter 2). And in this chapter comes the most quoted sentence of the book.
It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own interest.
We address ourselves not to their humanity but to their self-love, and talk not of our own necessities but of their advantages. Giving another what he wants in return for what I want, voluntary exchange, is what makes cooperation among strangers possible.
In chapter 3 Smith adds a limit: the division of labour is bounded by the extent of the market. In a village with few buyers, no one can live by making pins alone. The wider the market, the finer the division of work, and the richer people become.
The Village That Paid in Nails
Once labour is divided, a difficulty appears. The butcher has more meat than he can eat, and the brewer and the baker would buy some, but they have only bread and beer to offer and he already has enough of both. No exchange takes place. So every prudent man, Smith writes, tried to keep by him a quantity of some commodity that few would refuse, and many commodities took that role in turn (Book I, chapter 4).
Cattle in Homer's time, salt in Abyssinia, shells on parts of the Indian coast, dried cod in Newfoundland, tobacco in Virginia. And then an example from his own day.
there is at this day a village in Scotland, where it is not uncommon, I am told, for a workman to carry nails instead of money to the baker's shop or the ale-house.
In the end, every country chose metals. They hardly perish, so they can be kept without loss; they can be divided into any number of parts without loss, and melted together again. An ox cannot buy a handful of salt, but metal can be cut to exactly the amount needed. The stamp of the mint came afterwards: coined money began when a public office certified the quantity and fineness of metal, to spare people the trouble of weighing and assaying and the frauds that went with it.
This account of money growing out of the choices of people who trade, rather than from anyone's command, became the starting point when Carl Menger rewrote the origin of money a century later. Smith's conditions, that money last, divide well and resist counterfeiting, can be laid straight onto Bitcoin today.
The Avarice of Princes and the Clipped Coin
In the same chapter Smith notes that the names of coins were originally weights. The Roman as was a pound of copper; the English pound sterling was a pound of silver. The names stayed while the contents shrank.
in every country of the world, I believe, the avarice and injustice of princes and sovereign states, abusing the confidence of their subjects, have by degrees diminished the real quantity of metal, which had been originally contained in their coins.
By the late Republic the Roman as had fallen to a twenty-fourth of its original value. As Smith wrote, the English pound held about a third of its original value, the Scots pound about a thirty-sixth, and the French pound about a sixty-sixth.
By this means a prince appeared to pay his debts in full. Smith is blunt that it was appearance only: the creditors were really defrauded of part of what they were owed. Such operations always favoured the debtor and ruined the creditor, and sometimes overturned private fortunes more thoroughly than a great public calamity could have. Today we would call it an inflation tax, and it is the first argument advocates of sound money reach for.
The Wings of Paper Money
Smith did not oppose bank paper. In Book II, chapter 2, he compares the gold and silver in circulation to a highway: it carries all the grass and corn of the country to market but grows not a blade itself. By putting paper in place of metal, banks let a country turn much of that highway into pasture and corn fields, providing what Smith, apologising for the violence of the metaphor, called "a sort of waggon-way through the air." Then the warning follows at once.
The commerce and industry of the country, however, it must be acknowledged, though they may be somewhat augmented, cannot be altogether so secure, when they are thus, as it were, suspended upon the Daedalian wings of paper money, as when they travel about upon the solid ground of gold and silver.
Daedalus flew on wings fixed with wax, and his son Icarus flew too close to the sun and fell. Smith writes that besides the accidents caused by unskilful managers, there are others no prudence can guard against, such as an unsuccessful war in which the enemy takes the capital and the treasure that supported the credit of the paper.
The paper Smith had in mind was a banknote promising redemption in gold or silver on demand. Fiat money, which has dropped even that promise, is in his image a pair of wings with no way back to the ground.
The Invisible Hand
Now the famous passage. In Book IV, chapter 2, Smith asks whether imports should be restrained to protect domestic industry. Anyone with capital, he explains, tries to employ it where it yields the greatest value, and in doing so makes the annual revenue of the society as great as he can.
he intends only his own gain; and he is in this, as in many other cases, led by an invisible hand to promote an end which was no part of his intention.
The sentences that follow are sharper still. By pursuing his own interest he frequently promotes that of society more effectually than when he really intends to. And: "I have never known much good done by those who affected to trade for the public good."
Smith goes on to say that every individual, in his local situation, can judge much better than any statesman or lawgiver where his capital is best employed. A statesman who tried to direct private capital would load himself with a most unnecessary attention, and assume an authority that could safely be trusted to no single person and to no council or senate whatever, and that would be nowhere so dangerous as in the hands of a man foolish and presumptuous enough to think himself fit to exercise it. The idea that dispersed knowledge cannot be gathered in one head runs forward to Hayek's spontaneous order and Mises's economic calculation problem.
The invisible hand of The Theory of Moral Sentiments has a different texture. However greedy a landlord may be, the capacity of his stomach bears no proportion to his desires and holds no more than a peasant's. He must hand most of his harvest to those who furnish his house and make his trinkets. So the rich, though they mean only their own conveniency, "are led by an invisible hand to make nearly the same distribution of the necessaries of life, which would have been made, had the earth been divided into equal portions among all its inhabitants."
Sympathy and the Impartial Spectator
Read The Wealth of Nations alone and Smith seems to treat people as moved only by self-interest. But the book he wrote first, and kept revising all his life, was The Theory of Moral Sentiments, and its first sentence reads:
How selfish soever man may be supposed, there are evidently some principles in his nature, which interest him in the fortune of others, and render their happiness necessary to him, though he derives nothing from it, except the pleasure of seeing it.
Smith called this principle sympathy. We put ourselves in another's place, and know that others put themselves in ours. So a person comes to view his own conduct through the eyes of an "impartial spectator" within, and tones his passions down to a pitch that spectator could go along with. Morality, on this account, grows as people watch one another and adjust.
Nineteenth-century German scholars thought the self-interest of The Wealth of Nations contradicted the sympathy of The Theory of Moral Sentiments, and called this the "Adam Smith problem." Read together, the two books look less like a contradiction than a division of labour. One deals with exchange among strangers, the other with judgment among people who know each other. A society in which you need not count on the butcher's benevolence is also one in which people keep their promises because they feel each other's eyes.
The Pieces on the Chessboard
Shortly before his death Smith added a new part to the sixth edition of The Theory of Moral Sentiments. It contains a warning about those who would design a society.
He seems to imagine that he can arrange the different members of a great society with as much ease as the hand arranges the different pieces upon a chess-board.
This is "the man of system." But the pieces on a chessboard have no principle of motion except the one the hand gives them, whereas in the great chessboard of human society every piece has a principle of motion of its own, altogether different from the one the legislature might choose to impress on it. When the two coincide, Smith wrote, the game goes on easily and harmoniously; when they are opposed, society must be at all times in the highest degree of disorder.
Three Duties of the Sovereign
None of this made Smith an opponent of the state as such. In Book V he writes that once all systems of preference and restraint are taken away, "the obvious and simple system of natural liberty establishes itself of its own accord," and he gives the sovereign three duties under it: protecting society from invasion by other societies; protecting every member from the injustice or oppression of every other, through an exact administration of justice; and erecting and maintaining certain public works and institutions that no individual could profitably build, though they repay a great society many times over.
The list became the classic template of minarchy. What belongs under the third duty has been argued over ever since.
Limits and Disputes
One of Smith's largest legacies also became his largest weakness. At the end of Book I, chapter 4, he divides value into value in use and value in exchange.
Nothing is more useful than water; but it will purchase scarce any thing; scarce any thing can be had in exchange for it. A diamond, on the contrary, has scarce any value in use; but a very great quantity of other goods may frequently be had in exchange for it.
Smith left the gap unresolved and went on to look for the real measure of exchangeable value in labour. That road led through Ricardo to Marx's labour theory of value. The water-diamond puzzle was solved in the early 1870s, almost simultaneously, by Menger, Jevons and Walras through marginal utility, and the subjective theory of value, which locates value in the judgment of the person using a good rather than in the labour put into it, took over.
On interest, too, Smith stopped short of full freedom. He thought the legal maximum rate should sit only a little above the lowest market rate, in Britain then five per cent. Set the cap at eight or ten per cent and the only borrowers willing to pay would be "prodigals and projectors," and the country's capital would flow into their hands. In his Defence of Usury (1787), Jeremy Bentham devoted a whole letter, addressed "To Dr. Smith," to the reply that a cap on interest falls on everyone who strikes out into invention or improvement, since the riskier the new venture, the higher the interest it must pay.
His line from Book I, chapter 10, that people of the same trade seldom meet together without the conversation ending in a conspiracy against the public or some contrivance to raise prices, is also much quoted. But Smith says in the very next sentence that preventing such meetings by law would be inconsistent with liberty and justice, and adds only that the law "ought to do nothing to facilitate such assemblies, much less to render them necessary." What he distrusted was not the market but monopoly propped up by state privilege.
Major Works
- The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759) - an account of the origin of morality through sympathy and the impartial spectator, revised through the sixth edition of 1790
- An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations (1776) - division of labour, money, capital, trade and public finance; the starting point of modern economics
- Essays on Philosophical Subjects (1795) - the manuscripts spared from the fire, published after his death
Related Concepts
- Voluntary Exchange - how the butcher's self-interest becomes cooperation
- Spontaneous Order - the line of thought running from the invisible hand to Hayek
- Carl Menger - the economist who solved Smith's puzzle of value and rewrote the origin of money
- Marginal Utility - the answer to the water-diamond paradox
- Subjective Theory of Value - the theory of value that replaced the labour theory
- Sound Money - the view of money that continues Smith's critique of the clipped coin
- Minarchy - limiting the state to defence, justice and public works