John Locke
The philosopher of the Two Treatises who derived property from the body. Labour and the spoilage limit, the money that lifted it, no taxation without consent, and his case against debasing the coin in 1695, read from the original texts.
The Philosopher Who Gave Property a Wide Meaning
John Locke (1632-1704) was an English philosopher and physician who stands at the starting point of modern liberal political philosophy. In the Two Treatises of Government, published anonymously in 1689, he answered the question of why government exists with a single word: property.
But property for Locke meant more than land or money. In section 123 of the Second Treatise he gives the reason people form a society:
for the mutual preservation of their lives, liberties and estates, which I call by the general name, property.
Because life and liberty sit under the same name as estates, protecting property meant, for Locke, protecting persons. This idea became the frame of the natural rights tradition and of the argument for self-ownership.
Life
Physician, and Shaftesbury's Man
Locke was born in 1632 in Wrington, Somerset, to Puritan parents of modest means. He studied at Christ Church, Oxford, and before he was a political philosopher he was absorbed in medicine and experimental science.
In the late 1660s he joined the household of the statesman Anthony Ashley Cooper, later the first Earl of Shaftesbury, as physician and secretary. Shaftesbury led the Whigs who opposed a Catholic succession, and at his side Locke was also secretary to the Lords Proprietors of the Carolina colony.
Exile and 1689
After Shaftesbury broke with the king, fled abroad and died, Locke too left for the Netherlands in 1683. He returned to England only in February 1689, once the Glorious Revolution was over.
In that year his major works appeared almost together: An Essay Concerning Human Understanding, the English translation of the Epistola de Tolerantia he had written in Latin in Holland, and the Two Treatises. The Two Treatises and the Letter Concerning Toleration came out without his name, and Locke never publicly owned the Two Treatises during his lifetime.
Later Years
From 1696, when the Board of Trade was revived, Locke was its most influential member until 1700. He then retired to a friend's house at Oates in Essex, where he died on 28 October 1704.
Core Ideas
Property That Begins with the Body
The starting point of Locke's theory of property is section 27 of the Second Treatise:
every man has a property in his own person: this no body has any right to but himself. The labour of his body, and the work of his hands, we may say, are properly his.
From there Locke takes one more step. Whatever a person removes from what nature gave to all and mixes his labour with becomes his. Section 28 gives the famous example. When did the acorns he picked up under an oak begin to be his? When he digested them, when he ate them, when he boiled them, when he brought them home? Locke answers that if the first gathering did not make them his, nothing afterwards could. If the consent of all mankind had been needed, he adds, man would have starved in the midst of plenty.
This argument later came to be called the labour-mixing theory, the usual account of how private property begins.
The Limit of Spoilage
May a person then gather acorns without end? In section 31 Locke raises the objection himself and answers no:
As much as any one can make use of to any advantage of life before it spoils, so much he may by his labour fix a property in: whatever is beyond this, is more than his share, and belongs to others.
Section 27 ends with a second condition. Labour makes a thing its owner's "at least where there is enough, and as good, left in common for others." This is what later readers call the Lockean proviso. Locke himself did not worry much about it. In section 33 he says no one could think himself injured by another man's good draught of water when a whole river of the same water was left to him.
Later libertarians split over the proviso. Robert Nozick refined it and kept it inside his own theory, while Murray Rothbard dropped it altogether, on the ground that being the first to use an unowned resource takes nothing from anyone.
The Money That Lifted the Limit
The most interesting part of Locke's account begins in section 46, where money enters. The spoilage limit exists because things rot. What happens if they are exchanged for something that does not?
Locke says that someone who bartered plums that would rot in a week for nuts that would last a year did no injury. Nor did someone who gave his nuts for a piece of metal he liked the colour of and kept it all his life. What exceeds the bounds of just property is not the size of a possession but anything perishing uselessly in it. Section 47 follows:
And thus came in the use of money, some lasting thing that men might keep without spoiling, and that by mutual consent men would take in exchange for the truly useful, but perishable supports of life.
In section 48 Locke imagines an island with nothing fit to serve as money. However good the land left there, people would have no reason to hold more than their family could use. Only where there is something "both lasting and scarce", worth hoarding, do people begin to enlarge their possessions.
Locke held that the value of gold and silver comes from human consent (section 50). Measured by use they are nothing next to food or clothing, yet because people tacitly agreed on their worth they became a store that does not decay. What he asked of money comes down to three things: that it not spoil, that it be scarce, and that people take it of their own accord.
A money that meets all three through rules and the choice of its users rather than a state's guarantee appeared some three centuries later, which makes Locke's account of money worth rereading with Bitcoin in mind. Bitcoin does not spoil, its supply is fixed, and no one is compelled to accept it.
No Taxation Without Consent
Locke faces directly the contradiction of a government, set up to protect property, that takes it. Section 138 is short and firm:
for I have truly no property in that, which another can by right take from me, when he pleases, against my consent.
In section 140 he grants that government costs a great deal and that whoever enjoys its protection should pay his share, but insists that it must be with his own consent, given by himself or by representatives he has chosen. Whoever lays taxes without that consent "invades the fundamental law of property, and subverts the end of government."
Some seventy years later this passage crossed the Atlantic as "no taxation without representation." The consent Locke meant was the consent of the majority, and later thinkers such as Rothbard pushed the non-aggression principle further at exactly that point, demanding the consent of the individual.
Power Held in Trust Can Be Taken Back
For Locke the legislative is the supreme power, but only "a fiduciary power to act for certain ends" (section 149). Because it is entrusted for an end, it is forfeited when that end is betrayed, and it returns to those who gave it.
Who, then, decides whether a government has broken its trust? In section 240 Locke asks the question himself and answers:
The people shall be judge
Who should judge whether a trustee acts well, he asks, but the one who appointed him?
The Silver Coin Debate of 1695
Locke did not write about money only as a philosopher. In the 1690s England's silver coins had lost much of their weight to clippers who shaved their edges, and the government had to recoin. The question was the standard. William Lowndes, Secretary to the Treasury, proposed in a 1695 report that the new coins should carry no more silver than the clipped ones already in circulation. Less silver under the same name: a devaluation.
Locke answered him the same year in Further Considerations Concerning Raising the Value of Money. He began by noting that silver is unlike other measures. A yard or a quart may rest in anyone's hands, but silver is different:
It is the thing bargain'd for, as well as the measure of the bargain
Silver is the measure of the bargain and the very thing bargained for. So keeping a coin's name while reducing its silver does more than change a measure: it reduces what everyone who agreed to be paid in that coin actually receives. In his dedication Locke wrote that such a devaluation would "deprive great Numbers of blameless Men of a Fifth Part of their Estates." Lenders and those living on fixed rents and annuities would bear the whole of it.
In January 1696 Parliament passed an act to recoin the silver at the old standard. Locke's case had carried the day. The outcome was not smooth, though. While clipped coin was being called in, money ran short and trade stalled, and the loss the state absorbed was met with a window tax, levied by the number of windows in a house.
Locke's account of who pays when the name stays and the content shrinks still holds when people talk today about the inflation tax or sound money.
Limits and Disputes
Locke's legacy has its shadows. He was involved in drafting the Fundamental Constitutions of Carolina, which accepted slavery, and how far his part went is still argued. In section 49 he wrote that "in the beginning all the world was America," picturing the lands of Native Americans as uncultivated commons, a line of reasoning later used to justify colonial seizure of land.
Even so, Locke's idea that life, liberty and property come before government, and that government is only the means entrusted with guarding them, became the floor on which the whole later liberal tradition stands.
Major Works
- A Letter Concerning Toleration (1689) - the state has no say over the salvation of souls
- An Essay Concerning Human Understanding (1689) - the classic of empiricism, knowledge from experience
- Two Treatises of Government (1689) - against Filmer's divine right of kings; the origin, end and limits of government
- Some Considerations of the Consequences of the Lowering of Interest and Raising the Value of Money (1691)
- Further Considerations Concerning Raising the Value of Money (1695) - the case against devaluing the silver coin
Related Concepts
- Natural Rights - the rights to life, liberty and property that Locke systematized
- Self-Ownership - the starting point of liberal ethics, from section 27
- Private Property - labour-mixing and homesteading
- Non-Aggression Principle - Locke's natural rights turned into an axiom
- Murray Rothbard - dropped the Lockean proviso and carried natural rights to the end
- Sound Money - the principle Locke defended in the coin debate